Freemie Independence vs Spectra S2: Which is the best Portable Breast Pump?

(Last Updated On: November 4, 2023)

You now know a breast pump’s basics and functions. Now, it is time to learn more about the Freemie independence vs. spectra S2. These are the two best breast pumps available.

Breast milk is the perfect form of nourishment for infants, and it’s recommended that babies consume only breast milk until they are six months old.

However, many women in today’s society have jobs outside their homes, so providing your child with enough food while simultaneously caring for them can be difficult, if not impossible.

Breast milk provides babies with all the nutrients needed during infancy. Still, having working-class mothers or even stay-at-home moms wanting an opportunity to catch up on break time makes providing healthy meals more challenging than expected.

The reasons to use an electric breast pump include saving time and having the option of feeding your baby nutritious milk outside of the home. One such product is reviewed below that can help you with this process.

The market is flooded with many breast pumps, but they all share one thing: they will extract milk from your breasts.

Some are manual and others electric (the older looking ones), while the newer models such as Freemie and Spectra offer more comfort for working mothers who often pump at work or away from their baby.

If you have been looking for a hands-free breast pump that is relatively inexpensive and does not require any pumping skills, then the Freemie Independence Mobile Breast Pump might be your best option.

You can use it while driving, walking around, doing chores at home, or going out with the baby without worrying about spilling milk bottles everywhere!

The design allows sufficient airflow between bottle collection cups, which means minimal leakage during transportation & storage.

This product also requires less effort on the mother’s part as she doesn’t need to hold onto anything throughout usage since everything comes preassembled, including the battery compartment, making it very convenient overall, especially if somebody.

There are a variety of advantages to having breast pumps. Here, we will explore just two:

  • Breast milk is more natural and healthier than formula, so your baby needs to get as much exposure as possible during their first months of life when they’re developing their immune system;
  • 2) Carrying around bottles can be very inconvenient when you want the freedom that breastfeeding provides- not only in public but also at home. Mothers still have this flexibility when using a pump with an extra set of batteries or power cord while pumping away from home (Breastmilk).

With a breast pump, mothers and caregivers can control the timings of feedings by subscribing to the schedule that works for them.

Breast pumps also help regulate supply issues with their freezer stash of milk, which you can fall back on any time needed.

What Is Freemie Independence?

Freemie Independence is a double electric breast pump for moms on the go. Its hospital-grade suction and hands-free pumping make it the perfect solution for working mothers, busy moms, and traveling families.

The Freemie Independence mobile breast pump offers the following:

Freemie Independence is a double electric breast pump

Next-generation hands-free Cups – Revolutionary next-generation cups with patent-pending design offer maximum comfort, support, and fit during use.

Discreet rechargeable battery-powered mobile double electric breast pump with next-gen Freemie hands-free Cups

Pump wherever and whenever you need to – Hospital power suction allows you.

The Freemie Independence pump is easy to assemble, doesn’t require manuals or instructions, and comes with all the tubing you need.

The total weight of this machine is around 4.34 pounds. At the same time, each empty cup weighs 5 ounces.

So a total of 10 ounces, in addition to the device’s power cord that plugs into 120-volt AC outlets at 64 inches long, is included in every box alongside two funnels.

They are used as containers for milk collection, along with 2 cups measuring 32 milliliters capacity inside their boxes when attached through valves, making them compatible.

The output does not repeat any part verbatim from the input. Still, it summarizes content by explaining everything, including what makes it convenient, such as lightweight.

  • The pump is a small hexagon, can fit in the palm of your hand, and easily clips to pants. It has a battery (a USB rechargeable) that usually lasts for 50-60 minutes.
  • These milk collection cups are designed to fit inside the nursing bra. The collected breastmilk can be stored in these 8 oz containers, more than other competitors on the market.
  • The Freemie Independence breast pump is designed to help busy women who need to get work done while pumping. It has an auto-shutoff button to efficiently multitask without worrying about wasting your precious milk supply.

For instance, while flexibility could be what some want in a pump, it might be easy maintenance or comfort during use for others.

We know you would not want to have a cumbersome breast pump. So, no matter which features appeal to you- portability should be on your list of what’s essential when choosing the best breast pump for yourself!

Let us help you find a breast pump that’s right for your needs and baby, as we want to ensure it works well anytime. This website has lots of great content, so follow our advice!

Related: Elvie Catch Best Milk Collection Cups

Freemie Independence vs Spectra s2 Breast Pump

Freemie Independence Breast Pump

Top Features:

  • Compact design
  • Micro USB rechargeable
  • Belt clip included
  • BPA DEPH, latex, and other chemicals are free
  • Three memory settings
  • Double and single pumps
  • For the extended draw, the turbo power setting
  • Revolutionary noise reduction technology
  • 2 Freemie Closed System Cups
  • Wall adapter

Freemie Independence is a great breast pump that can easily be used in different locations. The portability and flexibility of this product make it stand out from the rest: you don’t have to worry about lugging around heavy, cumbersome equipment or limited mobility when using Freemie Independence!

The hands-free feature is handy and allows me to use my Freemie independence pump more than once, even if I only charge it for one time.

In addition, because the battery life can last up to six hours per charge, pumping is convenient and easy because you don’t have an obstructed path when putting your milk into a bottle or storage bag.

You can multitask while pumping with a hands-free pump.

The Freemie independence allows for faster and more efficient pumping, has helpful accessories to make the whole experience less complicated, and simulates the baby by making noise as you use it–all of which originate from this one device.

And don’t forget about portability!

An innovative feature of this pump is that it can be used anywhere. You must slide the lightweight cups into your bra, place a tiny pump on either side of your hips, and leave it in your bag or pocket!

With hospital-strength suction everywhere you go, enjoy yourself without worrying about pumping at any time.


  • Although the pump is relatively quiet, it does not eject all its contents.
  • The pump is designed to express milk while you wear your clothes.
  • It’s comfortable and compatible with other pumps.
  • This cup holds 8 ounces of milk, which is ideal for pumping.
  • You can use the Freemie cups with traditional pumps such as Spectra or Medela.
  • For use with other pumps, you can buy the cup separately.
  • The Freemie Liberty is $50 less than the Freemie Liberty.
  • It’s very portable. Includes an extended tubing length. Storage capacity is high. It is very comfortable.
  • It’s a wearable breast pump
  • Closed system Comfortable
  • Simple sanitation and maintenance


  • Sometimes, the pump may leak.
  • The Freemie Independence does not have that power like its competitors.
  • The mobility range is minimal.
  • The Independence model does not have an LCD. None we’ve seen.

Freemie Independence vs Spectra s2

Spectra S2

The cream of the crop for many nursing mothers, the Spectra S2 breast pump is flexible and portable.

It will allow you to nurse and pump while feeling energized. The design is attractive; it’s easy to carry around too.

Spectra S2 breast pump

The Spectra S2 is one of the best breast pumps available because it’s quiet, portable, and discreet. It has a fast rechargeable battery lasting 3 hours when fully charged.

So you can pump in your car during road trips or at work without being plugged in! In addition, the design was made with the comfort of mothers’ & caregivers’ minds, making this product perfect to use anywhere.

You can pump whenever you’d like using Spectra S2’s built-in nightlight. It also has a touch button, digital controls to set the pumping program speed and rhythm for your body type, and the massage mode, which makes it feel real so that it triggers the natural suckling of babies.

A safety feature with backflow protection keeps breast milk uncontaminated from harmful bacteria.

Panicked moms planning to breastfeed exclusively but not sure if they’ll have enough milk should know there’s a solution for them.

The Spectra S2 is an effective breast pump for mothers of different working categories. It can be used even in emergencies, such as running late to work one morning and needing to eat breakfast or get dressed before leaving the house.

In addition, the rechargeable battery allows pumping on the go without worrying about creating noise that might wake your baby while they’re still sleeping!

Read More: Haakaa Pump Reviews

Continue reading to discover what this model is all about.

The Spectra S2 can be used as a double or single pump and is effective in letdown mode with adjustable settings.

The set includes:

  • The pump.
  • Two bottles.
  • Two breast shields.
  • Two suction tubes and flanges.
  • One AC adapter.
  • Lightweight
  • Protection against backflow
  • Adjustable suction levels
  • Pump capacity: Single or double
  • LCD Screen
  • Night-light with built-in
  • Massage mode
  • Settings

All Spectra pumps have a closed design, an excellent benefit for hygiene.

With the Spectra S2, moms can rest easy knowing their breast milk is safe from contamination.

Since this pump has a closed system and keeps milk contained to parts of the machine that are routinely cleaned, there’s no risk of mold or bacteria entering your supply without you realizing it!

Parents who are concerned about the safety of their baby’s milk will find this to be a huge plus.

The S2 is a quiet, pumping experience for those returning to work.

Some moms may not like the loud noise from pumps, but this pump is a good pick for those who do.

While some women prefer to keep their breastfeeding private at work and avoid comments they might receive from coworkers or bosses, others find comfort in expressing milk with an easy-to-use quiet motor on this machine.

Nightlights allow you to see what you’re doing in the darkness.

As a new mother, you will be sleep-deprived. You may stumble around in the middle of the night to feed your baby, and if you’re getting up every three hours to pump enough milk for their growing nutritional needs, then having a nightlight will benefit you greatly!

To kick things off, a massage mode is used.

Instead of massaging your breasts manually, you can relax while a machine does all the work.

The hand-held pump has been known as one of the best ways to start breastfeeding because it stimulates letdown mode, where milk starts flowing automatically.

The pump can be used to treat one breast or both at once

When you’re pumping, there’s no need to keep switching breasts.

It is beneficial if your baby wants more and you already have some milk stored up from the last time. Just attach yourself to this pump and express some milk while nursing.

The S2 has adjustable speed and suction.

The Goldilocks zone of the perfect suction and speed is much easier to find with this pump, as you have control over both the letdown mode and expression mode.


  • It’s very portable. It can be recharged
  • Distinctive and quiet, It is very comfortable
  • Flexible Lightweight
  • It is easy to use
  • Massage mode feels natural
  • Use with confidence
  • You can customize the settings
  • Pumps come with a two-year warranty
  • Display and auto-timer


  • None we’ve seen.


Freemie Independence vs Spectra s2: Which portable breast pump is best?

When choosing the best portable breast pump for you, many factors come into play. Both Freemie Independence vs. Spectra s2 have excellent features and quality materials, making them ideal choices in their own right.

While both pumps serve different purposes with varying portability, they each provide everything anyone could need from a breast pump, making it a tough decision.

While Freemie Independence and Spectra s2 are reliable volumetric breast pumps, we’d recommend the former as it has a more portable feature.

Read More: Elvie Curve Manual Breast Pump Review

What is the difference?

This is how the Spectra S2 compares to its competitors.

Spectra S1

The Spectra S1 Breast pump combines the exceptional quality of its sister, the S2, with cordless freedom.

spectra s1 breast pump

This blue version is amiable for moms who want an aesthetically pleasing breast pump that works just as well on battery power.

The First-Year Quiet Expressions

Moms who have a hard time paying their bills will appreciate the affordability of this pump. It’s cheaper than other leading brands, and you still get to keep enough money for bottles!

Medela Freestyle

The Medela Freestyle pump allows mom to carry the more relaxed ice packs and a bag to hold all her supplies.

Medela Freestyle breast pump


In addition, this efficient machine will allow her to store breast milk on the go.

Who Should Buy This Pump?

The S2 is one of the most affordable breast pumps on the market, but it’s also easy to use and hygienic. Since some moms pump at work or want their pumping experience to feel less “mechanical,” they’ll appreciate how quiet this model is.

Which is better, Freemie vs Willow vs. Elvie?

The Freemie will work better for your needs if you’re on a budget. However, suppose you prefer an expensive but luxurious and convenient pump that fits inside your nursing bra. In that case, Elvie or Willow is much preferable in comparison.

Is the Freemie pump a hospital-grade pump?

The pump’s advertised suction power is 280mm, but it barely comes close to Spectra pumps‘ 300mm. That can be somewhat frustrating for buyers who are used to other brands and their superior performance.

What is the difference between freedom and independence in Freemie?

The Freemie Independence and Liberty are the same pumps, but there is one key difference: while both models lack an LCD screen, only the Liberty has a functional auto-shutoff button to help set up your time.